Lake Maxinkuckee Its Intrigue
History & Genealogy


Culver, Marshall, Indiana

Home | Contact Us | What's New | Search This Site| Site Map   | Forum 

List of Cottagers & Property Owners East Shore
This is probably an incomplete listing probably of cottage lots and owners - but this is what was listed on the plat map of 1908 and what I am able to decipher of it. I hope to connect everything from the 1876 plat map forward but that will take time and much more research - in hopes of making an accurate history and genealogy of thelake and along the way gathering pictures, maps, stories, myths, legends, biographies, obitauries etc. to enhance it.

None of these listings are eteched in stone - it is probably just a pratial listing from sources during this time period - and based on known facts of 1908, on the plat map - everything may change if I can ever get the use of some of the abstracts or cottagers step forth with corrected data.

I will try and carry this data forward to each of the plat maps if I can connect from this one to the next.

Hopefully from deeds, abstracts and future research we can list the complete property owners at this time.

There are several east side shore scenes and cottages that have not been identified as yet - they are presented here.

Cottage reported to be built after 5 April 1906 by J. O. Frerrier are:
  • Vagen cottage at a cost of $2500-3000
  • H/B Haymond of Indianapols on the southeast corner of the lake at a cost of $800-1000

I have subdivided the east shore into 2 sections the north and south half and then further down as illustrated below  

 

Culver Place
1908 - H. H. Culver Est.

1908 - on east side of St. Rd. 117 Lot 4 - H. H. Culver Est. - 6.50A
1837 - 10 August - William Thompson
1876 - G. Peoples
1898 - H. Mc Keen
1908 - ?Mc Keen? could this be the McKeen of the Vandalia/Pennsylvania Railroad???

1908 - H. H. Culver est.
1908 - Geo. People [George Peeples/Peoples]

1908 - on east side of St. Rd. 1117 Geo. Peoples 8.90 A [George Peeples/Peoples]

easement to lake


House of A 1000 Candles - 762 East Shore Drive
1908 - Potts [Alfred Fremont Potts]

1908 Vonnegut

1908 - Vonnegut

1837 - 10 August - William Thompson
1876 - 1880 - G. Peoples [George Peeples/Peoples]
1898 - no name listed
1908 - Geo. Peoples [George Peeples/Peoples]

1908 - Geo. Peoples 37.47A east side of St. Rd. 117 extends from the Potts property to Wheeler est. or Blain property - residence on property [George Peeples/Peoples]

1898 - no name listed
1908 - Miller

1880 - J. S. Hale etal ?
1908 - Otto Stechhan - Indiana Boathouse
From the 1886 15th Annual Report to the Governor MAXINKUCKEE W. H. Thompson & S. E. Lee

Mr. Stechorn, near Mr. Culver, has a well fifty feet deep, which has a small flow.

Hilarity Hill" 1880 - J. M. Mahfield/Muhlfiled [John Muhlfield]
1898 - C. A. B. & C. J. Keifer
1908 - Kiefer

1880 Boggs & Co.
1898 - W. C. Vafan/Willis C. Vajen
From the 1886 15th Annual Report to the Governor MAXINKUCKEE W. H. Thompson & S. E. Lee

Farther east, Mr. Willis H. Vajen has a good well which flows nine teen feet above the surface of the lake. This bore showed forty feet of continuous clay, followed by ten feet of sand.

5 May 1904 - Geo. Yandes of Indianapolis arrived at the lake Wednesday. He recently bouth the Willis Vajen cottage and will have it remodeled before the season opens.

16 June 1904 - Geo. B. Yandes and neices Misses Robinson of Indianpolis have opened their cottage the Echo
1908 - Yandes
1908 - Ketchem

1880 - Peru Club
1898 - Peru Club lot
1908 - Chas. Brawnell/Brownell [Charles H. Brownell]
From the 1886 15th Annual Report to the Governor MAXINKUCKEE W. H. Thompson & S. E. Lee

Near Mr. Vajen's place, on the east, the Peru Club has its Club House, and here the club has bored to a depth of one hundred and sixty feet, ending in obdurate hardpan. The flow of water from some higher stratum of sand is weak, being about an eighth of an inch from a two-inch pipe. No section could be obtained.

1880 - Rector & Thomas
1898 - Bay View Club
From the 1886 15th Annual Report to the Governor MAXINKUCKEE W. H. Thompson & S. E. Lee

Farther east, "Bay View," the Indianapolis Club House, has a good well only twenty-eight feet deep.


1908 E. B. Porters Subdivision - there are six lots - No Names

Easement to lake

1898 - A. Brunner?
1908 - Miller
From the 1886 15th Annual Report to the Governor MAXINKUCKEE W. H. Thompson & S. E. Lee

The next well is on the lot of Mr. George W. Miller, of Peru, who has built no cottage, but with his family passes the summers in a large tent. His well is fifty feet deep, and was driven by two men in three hours. The per cent. of iron in the water from this well is evidently much less than in most others near it.

1898 - G. Peeples
1908 - ?Millagth?_

Shady Bluff
1898 - R. Wheeler?


1900 - Wm. E. Wheeler
1903 - Newspaper snippets mentions Shady Bluff and these two names in connection with it: Harry Wheeler - Westfield, Ill. and Robert Morrison, Indianapolis

1908 - Unreadable/Blain

1908 - D. W. & E. Marmon [Daniel W. Marmon & Elizabeth Carpenter Maromon]

1908 on east side of St. Rd. 117 - D. & E. Marmon 12.27a

1898 - M. B. & J. E. Dill [H. B. & J. B. Dill?]
From the 1886 15th Annual Report to the Governor MAXINKUCKEE W. H. Thompson & S. E. Lee

South of Mormon's place J. B. Dill has a good flow, reached at a depth of twenty feet.
1908 - H. Bliss [Henry R. Bliss]

1898 - J. H. & A. Vafen/John Henry Vajen and Alice (Fugate) Vajen
From the 1886 15th Annual Report to the Governor MAXINKUCKEE W. H. Thompson & S. E. Lee

The well bored by Hon. J. H. Vajen, at his beautiful place next south of Mr. Dill, was begun at a point eleven feet above the surface of the lake, and showed the following strata:

Soil and clay 6 ft.
Sand 3 ft.
Blue clay 23 ft.
Total 32 ft.

Mr. Vajen dug a well several years ago, which, on reaching a depth of eight feet, began to flow a milk-white water of about the consistency of cream, and which deposited a silicious, lime-like marl, and whitened the water of the lake for a distance of thirty feet from the water's edge. In the back part of Mr. Vajen's lot was a low. wet spot, which began to sink when the well began to flow,"and continued to sink until the white flow changed to clear, pure water. Mr. Vajen has utilized the pressure of water from his well, the stream running a ram which supplies his premises with water, and also furnishes the power which revolves the beautiful colored light at the landing pier before his gate.

High upon the hill beside the Plymouth road, about one hundred yards from the lake, and fully thirty feet above it, gushes out the "Original Spring," as it is known, which pointed the index finger toward the first flowing well. This spring pours out a four-inch stream, and the boring of wells has never diminished the flow.

1908 - on east side of St. Rd. 117 - J. H. & A. Vafen/John Henry Vajen and Alice (Fugate) Vajen

1908 - H. Bliss [Henry R. Bliss]
Indianapolis, Indiana city directory (Volume yr.1899) by ... Bliss Henry R, sec and treas The Sinker- Davis Co, h 1817 N Meridian.

Indianapolis Blue Book 1913...Bliss Mrs Henry R (Margaret Hooker), 2905 North Meridian street, Mr Henry W Bliss...

1898 - no name listed ?
1908 - H. Bliss [Henry R. Bliss]

1898 - on east side of St. Rd. 117 - J. H. & A. Vafen/John Henry Vajen and Alice (Fugate) Vajen
1908 on east side of St. Rd. 117 - J. & A. Vagen/John Henry Vajen and Alice (Fugate) Vajen

easement to lake

 

1880 - Rector & Thomas 85A
1898 - Martin & Strain - Martin Box
1908 - Jos. Strong [Joseph Strong]
    1880 - Rector & Thomas ?32A? & 85A
    1908 - Lot 2 (part of) - M. F. Louden
    1908 - Lot 2 (part of) - W. Hunt

1880 - Rector & Thomas 85A
1908 - Lewis B. Martin est.

1880 - Rector & Thomas 85A
1898 - Not Stated
1908 -
    Lakefront half: Shoemold
    ?Engl3/English Est.? [on the road side]

1908 - Milton Shirk

1908 - T. J. Bigley/Store [Thomas J. Bigley]

1880 - On east side of St. Rd. 117 Rector & Thomas 85A
1908 - On east side of St. Rd. 117 Lot 2 (part of) - Sarah A. Rector 22.10, Hotel and Livery / Rector Hotel near corner of St. Rd. 117 & 18thB Rd.

Maxinkuckee Landing

The East side Historic District - the official recording of this is: Also known as Lake Maxinkuckee Historic District - - Roughly, E Shore Dr. from W. 18th Rd.,to the E turn of IN 117, including Maxinkuckee
Country Club, Culver. But a map I found expands it further north of the landing.

1880 - Rector & Thomas 32a
1898 - W. C. Vagin/Willis C. Vajen - Sea Beach - large lot
1908 - Sea Beach Place Subdivision (1898)
    1908 - Lots 1 - 2
    1908 - Lots 3 - 4
    1908 - Lots 5
    1908 - Lot 6
    1908 - Lot 7 & 8
    1908 - Lot 9 & 10

1908 - on east side of St. Rd. 117 extends these Lots of Sea Beach Place - M. F. Louden - 9.07

1908 - on east side of St. Rd. 117 1908 - Maxinkuckee Golf Course Opens

easement to lake

1876 - J. C. Miles [John C. Miles]
?
1880 - Halycon Club - H. B. Scott 34.50A
Edwards Boath House
1908 - R. A. Edwards [Richard A. Edwards]

There are 2 areas that could be the location refered to as Edwards Landing this being the first and the other is the area down around the E. Shore Lane where the Bide-a-wee was and the Edwards familly had cottages

Aub-bee-naub-bee creek

1898 - W. C. Vagin/Willis C. Vajen - Sea Beach - large lot
    1908 - Lot 11,12 & 13
    1908 - Lot 14
    1908 - Lot 15
    1908 - Lot 16
    1908 - Lot 17 & 18

1908 - on east side of St. Rd. 117 extends these Lots of Sea Beach Place Lot 3 - Chas. E. Coffin [Charles Emmett Coffin]-

1908 - J. Schaf [Joseph Charles Schaf] & M. Maus


1908 - Wm. W. Winslow [said to have purchased 1896]

1908 - A. M. Dossbrenner/Glossbrenner [Alfred M. Glossbrenner]

1908 - Manwood

1908 - on east side of St. Rd. 117 J. L Bartlett - 2 lots
1908 - on east side of St. Rd. 117 Michael Burkett Lot 3 12.51a

1908 - Buck
easement

1908 - no name

1908 - no name

1908 - no name

1908 - no name

1908 - no name

1908 - no name

1908 - on east side of St. Rd. 117 Charlotte Bates - 5.55a
1908 - on east side of St. Rd. 117 Charlotte Bates - Hervey Bates - 4a

1898 - Logansport Settlement
1908 - Logansport Settlement     1908 - Lot 6 & 5
    1908 - Lot 4, 3, & 2
    1908 - Lot 1

1908 - on east side of St. Rd. 117 Hervey Bates - 5a
1908 - on east side of St. Rd. 117 - S. L. Purcell

1908 - Jamison [Ovid Butler Jamison] & Judah [John Mantle Judah]

1908 - on east side of St. Rd. 117 - S. L. Purcell

1898 - H. E. Schroyer
1908 - H. Schroyer

1908 - H. C. Adams [Henry C. "Harry" Adams]


1898 - Rice Vaughn
1908 - Rice Vaughn

1908 - A. W.

1863 - L. T. Van Shoiack [Louden T. Van Shoiak] 
1876 - L. T. Van Shoiack [Louden T. Van Shoiak] 
1880 - L. T. Van Shoiack - 105.80A [Louden T. Van Shoiack]
1898 - L. T. Van Shoiack [Louden T. Van Shoiak]   - [non lake property 45.70A &59.98]



VanSoiak Farm

1873 - Lake View Club
1880 - R. Mc Quat [Robert L. Mc Quat]
1908 - E. B. Mc Qout/Mc Quat [Eugenia B. Mc Quat]

1908 - Large un-number lot

1908 - on east side of St. Rd. 117 1898 - J. T. Van Shoiak - 45.70a

1908 - Lot # 1 Lovina Walker Etal It extends from the North in the middles of Lot #1 of the Logansport Settlement to the south ending at the J. A. Maxwell property

1898 - J. A. Maxwell
1908 - J. A. Maxwell

1863 - L. T. Van Shoiack [Louden T. Van Shoiak] 
    [Louden T. VanShoiack owned 1/2 mile of lake front & 200 Acres to the east]
1876 - L. T. Van Shoiack [Louden T. Van Shoiak] 
1880 - L. T. Van Shoiack [Louden T. Van Shoiak] 105.80
    - 1898 - G. Schull
    - 1898 - T. Day
    - 1898 - D. E. Burford
        1904 Aug. E. A. Ellsworth
    - ? - May 1893 Lot #4 - John F. & Mary Wallick, sold for $2000.
      - May 1893-1898 A. M. Ogle
    - 1898 - J. A. Ronihasler
    - 1898 - M. C. Gilland
    - 1898 - J. M. Dosser [Dresser]
    - 1898 - M. H. Stuart
    - 1898 - E. Ward
    - 1898 - J. M. Dosser [Dresser]
        VanShoiack Subdivision
        1908 - Lot 1 - Lovina Walker Etal & Lot 1
        1908 - Lot 2
        1908 - Lot 3
        1908 - Lot 4
        1908 - Lot 5
        1908 - Lot 6
        1908 - Lot 7

1898 - Wm. Daggitt
1908 - Wm. Daggett

1898 - C. E. Daggitt
1908 - C. E. Daggett

1908 - Van Shaiacks/VanShoiack
1898 - east side of St. Rd. 117 possibly J. T. Van Shoiak - 59.98
1908 - east side of St. Rd. 117 Lot # 2 Lovina Walker Etal. 103.48a 1908 - east side of St. Rd. 117 Lovina Walker etal- small lot 1908 - east side of St. Rd. 117 Wm. Van Schoiack - 2 smaller lots
    It extends from the north of J. A. Maxwell property to the south ending at Van Schoiack's large lake front plot

 

1837 - June 30 - Land Patent to James F. D. Lanier
1846 - Francis Edwards
1880 - S. Edwards 78.80A [Stephen Edwards]
1898 - F. Ward
1908 - M.& J. Craig

1837 - June 30 - Land Patent to James F. D. Lanier
1846 - Francis Edwards
1880 - S. Edwards 78.80A [Stephen Edwards]
1898 - J. M. Dosser [Dresser] - Willow Springs
1908 - Irwin or Irwia

easment to lake

1837 - June 30 - Land Patent to James F. D. Lanier
1846 - Francis Edwards
1880 - S. Edwards 78.80A [Stephen Edwards]
1898 - Wm. Daggitt
1908 - C. Edwards

1837 - June 30 - Land Patent to James F. D. Lanier
1846 - Francis Edwards
1880 - S. Edwards 78.80A [Stephen Edwards]
1898 - C E. Daggitt
1908 - M. B. Henderson
    W. H. Henderson of Indianapolis has purchased ground of Stephen Edwards and erected a cottage which is a model and a credit to the lake. - 7 jUL 1903 cULVER cITIZEN

1837 - June 30 - Land Patent to James F. D. Lanier
1846 - Francis Edwards
1898 - S. E. Edwards 37.73A & 40A [Stephen E. Edwards]
1908 - S. Edwards & (also Stephen Edwards Lot #3 - 72.83A}

1908 - easement for S. Foss [Stephen Foss] property behind W. H. Fulton property ?
Veda Foss Fitterling wrote in the biography of "Fitterlings of Culver" in the 1986 Marshall County history: "..I only remember my great Uncle who with his wife Rebecca Stoever, owned and operated the Bide-a-Wee Hotel. He taught school for a short period of time..."
There are 2 areas that could be the location refered to as Edwards Landing the first being the the area of the Halycon Club or boathouse & later the the Edwards Boathouse at Aub-bee-naub-bee creek and the other is here where the Bide-a-wee was and the Edwards familly had cottages

1837 - June 30 - Land Patent to James F. D. Lanier
1846 - Francis Edwards
1880 - S. Edwards 78.80A [Stephen Edwards]
1898 - S. E. Edwards 37.73A & 40A [Stephen E. Edwards]
1908 - D. Gardiner

1837 - June 30 - Land Patent to James F. D. Lanier
1846 - Francis Edwards
1880 - S. Edwards 78.80A [Stephen Edwards]
1898 - S. E. Edwards 37.73A & 40A [Stephen E. Edwards]
1908 - W. H. Fulton

1837 - June 30 - Land Patent to James F. D. Lanier
1846 - Francis Edwards
1880 - S. Edwards 78.80A [Stephen Edwards]
1898 - S. E. Edwards 37.73A & 40A [Stephen E. Edwards]
1908 - W. H. Fulton

1837 - June 30 - Land Patent to James F. D. Lanier
1846 - Francis Edwards
1880 - S. Edwards 78.80A [Stephen Edwards]
1898 - S. E. Edwards 37.73A & 40A [Stephen E. Edwards]
1908 - W. H. Fulton

1837 - June 30 - Land Patent to James F. D. Lanier
1846 - Francis Edwards
1880 - S. Edwards 78.80A [Stephen Edwards]
1898 - S. E. Edwards 37.73A & 40A [Stephen E. Edwards]
1908 - H. B. Heywood

Cottage reported to be built after 5 April 1906 by J. O. Frerrier are: ... H/B Haymond of Indianapols on the southeast corner of the lake at a cost of $800-1000
1837 - June 30 - Land Patent to James F. D. Lanier
1846 - Francis Edwards
1880 - S. Edwards 78.80A [Stephen Edwards]
1898 - S. E. Edwards 37.73A & 40A [Stephen E. Edwards]
1898-1908 - W. J. Wood - Woodbank Cottage William Jacob Wood/Jacob Wood]



Maple Grove Farm, Also known as Maple Grove Hotel & Maple Grove Boarding House